Protecting Teachers or Protecting Children? Media Representations of Vergara v. California
https://doi.org/10.17583/rise.2017.2328
Downloads
Abstract
Over the past five years, the laws governing teachers’ employment have been at the center of legal and political conflicts in state courts and elections across the United States. Vergara v. California challenged five California state statutes that provide employment protections for teachers. Drawing on the theory of political spectacle, we conducted a media content analysis of 42 print news media articles published prior to the court’s decision in June 2014. Two aspects of political spectacle, the use of metaphor and the illusion of rationality were the most salient and deployed in ways that were more closely aligned with the student plaintiffs’ claims than the statutes’ defenders. We conclude by highlighting how the framing of these and other similar stories may shape subsequent debates about public education in the United States.
Downloads
References
Adler, M. (2013). Findings vs. interpretation in “The long-term impacts of teachers” by Chetty et al. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 21(10). Retrieved online from http://epaa.asu.edu/ojs/article/view/1264.
Google Scholar CrossrefAgrawal, J., & Kamakura, W. A. (1995). The economic worth of celebrity endorsers: An event study analysis. The Journal of Marketing, 56-62.
Google Scholar CrossrefAllegretto, S., Jacobs, K., & Lucia, L. (2011, October). The wrong target: Public sector unions and state budget deficits (Policy brief). Berkeley, CA: UC Berkeley Labor Center.
Google Scholar CrossrefAltheide, D. & Schneider, C. J. (2013). Qualitative media analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Google Scholar CrossrefAmerican Statistical Association (2014, April 8). ASA statement on using value-added models for educational assessment. Retrieved from https://www.amstat.org/policy/pdfs/ASA_VAM_Statement.pdf.
Google Scholar CrossrefAmrein-Beardsley, A. (2008). Methodological concerns about the education value-added assessment system. Educational researcher, 37(2), 65-75.
Google Scholar CrossrefAron, H. (2016, August 22). State court upholds California teacher tenure laws. LA Weekly. Retrieved from: http://www.laweekly.com/news/state-court-upholds-california-teacher-tenure-laws-7288336.
Google Scholar CrossrefAronowitz, S. (2011, June). One, two, many Madisons. The war on public sector workers. New Labor Forum, 20(2), 15-21.
Google Scholar CrossrefBaker, B. D., Oluwole, J. O., & Green, P. C. (2013). The legal consequences of mandating high stakes decisions based on low quality information: Teacher evaluation in the Race-to-the-Top era. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 21(5), 1-71.
Google Scholar CrossrefBarabas, J., & Jerit, J. (2009). Estimating the causal effects of media coverage on policy‐specific knowledge. American Journal of Political Science, 53(1), 73-89.
Google Scholar CrossrefCeasar, S. (2014a, January 26). Lawsuit targets teacher job security; it contends that state laws on the tenure, seniority and dismissal of educators violate the constitution. Los Angeles Times, p. A.27.
Google Scholar CrossrefCeasar, S. (2014b, January 27). Trial over California teacher protection laws opens. Los Angeles Times, p. AA.3.
Google Scholar CrossrefChetty, R., Friedman, J., & Rockoff, J. (2014). Measuring the impact of teachers II: The long-term impacts of teachers. American Economic Review, 104(9), 2633-2679.
Google Scholar CrossrefCorcoran, T & Goertz, M. (2005). The governance of public education. In S. Fuhrman and M. Lazerson (eds.) The Public Schools (pp 25-56). New York: Oxford University Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefCohen, J. (2010). Teachers in the news: A critical analysis of one US newspaper’s discourse on education, 2006-2007. Discourse: Studies in Cultural Politics of Education, 31(1), 105-119.
Google Scholar CrossrefCook, T. E. (1998). Governing with the news. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefDarling-Hammond, L., Amrein-Beardsley, A., Haertel, E., & Rothstein, J. (2012).Evaluating teacher evaluation. Phi Delta Kappan, 93(6), 8-15.
Google Scholar CrossrefDedoose Version 5.0.11, web application for managing, analyzing, and presenting qualitative and mixed method research data. (2014). Los Angeles, CA: SocioCultural Research Consultants, LLC (www.dedoose.com).
Google Scholar CrossrefDeutsch, L. (2014, January 26). California students file suit aimed at tenure law. San Jose Mercury News.
Google Scholar CrossrefEdelman, M. (1988). Constructing the political spectacle. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefEdwards, H. S. (2014). The war on teacher tenure. Time 184(17), 34-39.
Google Scholar CrossrefFensterwald, J. (2015, July 16). Students Matter sues districts over teacher evaluations. EdSource. Retrieved online from http://edsource.org/2015/students-matter-sues-districts-over-teacher-evaluations/83103.
Google Scholar CrossrefFirst Amended Complaint, Vergara v. California, Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles (BC484642) (2012).
Google Scholar CrossrefGabriel, R. & Lester, J. N. (2013). The romance quest of education reform: A discourse analysis of the Los Angeles Times’ reports on value-added measurement teacher effectiveness. Teachers College Record, 115(120307).
Google Scholar CrossrefGentzkow, M. & Shapiro, J. M. (2011). Ideological segregation online and offline. Quarterly Journal of Economics 126(4), 1799-1839.
Google Scholar CrossrefGoldie, D., Linick, M., Jabbar, H., & Lubienski, C. (2014). Using bibliometric and social media analysis to explore the “echo chamber” hypothesis. Educational Policy, 28(2), 281-305.
Google Scholar CrossrefGoldstein, R. A. (2011). Imaging the frame: Media representations of teachers, their unions, NCLB, and education reform. Educational Policy, 25(4), 543-576.
Google Scholar CrossrefHaas, E. M., Fischman, G. E., & Brewer, J. (2014). Dumb Ideas Won't Create Smart Kids: Straight Talk About Bad School Reform, Good Teaching, and Better Learning. Teachers College Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefHaas, E., & Fischman, G. (2010). Nostalgia, entrepreneurship, and redemption Understanding prototypes in higher education. American Educational Research Journal, 47(3), 532-562.
Google Scholar CrossrefJerit, J., Barabas, J., & Bolsen, T. (2006). Citizens, knowledge, and the information environment. American Journal of Political Science, 50(2), 266-282.
Google Scholar CrossrefJones, B. (2012, May 16). Civics lesson; Students file suit over bad teachers; schools: tenure laws deprive them of quality education, the group alleges. Los Angeles Daily News.
Google Scholar CrossrefLakoff, G. (2008). The political mind: A cognitive scientist's guide to your brain and its politics. New York: Penguin.
Google Scholar CrossrefLakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors we live by. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefMedina, J. (2014, April 16). Competing views of teacher tenure are on display in California case. The New York Times, p. A12.
Google Scholar CrossrefMedina, J & Rich, M. (2016, April 15). California appeals court reverses decision to overturn teacher tenure rules. New York Times, A13
Google Scholar CrossrefMcCombs, M. (2004). Setting the agenda: The mass media and public opinion. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Google Scholar CrossrefMeasures of Effective Teaching Project. (2015). MET FAQ. Retrieved from: http://www.metproject.org/faq.php
Google Scholar CrossrefMittelstaedt, J. D., Riesz, P. C., & Burns, W. J. (2000). Why are endorsements effective? Sorting among theories of product and endorser effects. Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising, 22(1), 55-65.
Google Scholar CrossrefMoses, M.S., & Saenz, L.P. (2008). Hijacking education policy decisions: Ballot initiatives and the case of affirmative action. Harvard Educational Review, 78(2), 289-310.
Google Scholar CrossrefPivovarova, M., Amrein-Beardsley, A., & Broatch, J. (2016). Value-added models (VAMs): Caveat emptor. Statistics and Public Policy (forthcoming). Retrieved from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/2330443X.2016.1164641
Google Scholar CrossrefSaenz, L. P., & Moses, M. S. (2010). Deliberating about affirmative action: Linking education policy research and the media. American Journal of Education, 116.
Google Scholar CrossrefSawchuk, S. (2012, June 5). Critics ask California courts to change teacher policies. Education Week, pp. 21, 23.
Google Scholar CrossrefSawchuk, S. (2014, February 3). Teachers' job protections debated in California trial. Education Week, pp. 1, 12-13.
Google Scholar CrossrefSchrag, P. (2014, Apr 03). Kill tenure, cure schools? Vergara vs. California may change rules, but it may not help kids. Los Angeles Times, p. A15.
Google Scholar CrossrefShoemaker, P. J. & Reese, S. D. (2013). Mediating the Message in the 21st Century. New York: Routledge.
Google Scholar CrossrefSmith, M. L. (2004). Political spectacle and the fate of American schools. New York: Routledge.
Google Scholar CrossrefStone, D. (2002). The policy paradox: The art of political decisionmaking. New York: W. W. Norton.
Google Scholar CrossrefStudents Matter. (n.d.). About Us. Retrieved from: http://studentsmatter.org/about/.
Google Scholar CrossrefSzymanski, M. (2016, May 24). Just in: Vergara appeal filed to California supreme court, LA School Report. Retrieved from: http://laschoolreport.com/vergara-appeal-filed-to-california-supreme-court/.
Google Scholar CrossrefWood, D. B. (2014, January 28). Vergara v. California: Do state laws protect teacher jobs over students? The Christian Science Monitor.
Google Scholar CrossrefDownloads
Published
Almetric
Dimensions
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
All articles are published under Creative Commons copyright (CC BY). Authors hold the copyright and retain publishing rights without restrictions, but authors allow anyone to download, reuse, reprint, modify, distribute, and/or copy articles as the original source is cited.